Facebook  Twitter  LinkedIn  

Visit min's sister site:



BREAKING NEWS & VIEWS

Update/Clarification on Entrepreneur/Scott Smith Story
Thursday, November 1, 2007

Scott Smith is not in fact suing Entrepreneur Media, but rather opposing their trademarks in the areas of “radio and television programs” and “pre-recorded audio and video.” In addition, Entrepreneur’s trademark, was found to be strong by the 9th circuit, and is therefore protected in its registered areas against any other products that use the word and may cause likelihood of confusion.

According to Neil Perlman, president of Entrepreneur Media, Smith was contacted before the lawsuit was served, as well as during the trial and appeal periods, in an effort to change his company’s name to something acceptable for both companies. This is standard practice when Entrepreneur discovers a company whose name could confuse the two brands.

Perlman said Smith refused, went on to lose both the court case and appeal, and that his new opposition stems from Smith’s belief that the trademark is too general despite the court ruling otherwise.

However, during Smith’s 2003 case, the court ruled that in the past 25 years since it was registered, the name’s extensive advertising and public recognition “established the plaintiff’s [Entrepreneur’s] mark as a strong mark in the industry.” In addition, according to the ruling of the appeal to the 9th circuit court, “[Entrepreneur] provided strong credible evidence that Smith intended to confuse customers.”

Also, the lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal has not been served. It was prepared and sent to WSJ, which is currently in discussion with Entrepreneur about changing its mark.

Perlman said Entrepreneur’s efforts are because unless a trademark is regularly protected, it loses its protected status. He said both the public and businesses benefit from trademark victories, as neither the small business nor the large corporation need worry about inferior products using its name to make a profit.

“It’s not the big guy against the little guy,” Perlman said. “We have to take a stand and protect our mark.”

The original story can be found here. minonline regrets for any confusion the story might have caused.

If you have breaking news to share please contact Steve Smith at ssmith@accessintel.com

COMMENTS
Search Jobs
Media Jobs

App Central

min's App Central (for min subscribers only): Stay on top of mobile app developments with exclusive app reviews, analysis and data.

Please enter the following information to have a link to The Skinny emailed to your iPhone:

White Papers
Get even smarter -- download a white paper today. 


... view Whitepapers
min Contests

min contests
Want to sponsor a min contest?


  Events

      Best of the Web, April 3, 2012

min's Sales Executive of the Year Awards
Call for Entries


min Press

min's Mobile App Report

 View Details
                           

min Presents: The Most Intriguing & Top-Selling Magazine Covers 2007-2010Intriguing & Top-Selling Magazine Covers

 View Details
                           

State of Digital MediaThe State of Digital Media

 View Details
                                                      

                                    Internet Sales            Guidebook

 View Details

All min Press

Inside min This Week
Events Calendar

min's Best of the Web Awards
Event April 3, 2012 at the Grand Hyatt, NYC
Register Today!


min Webinar:

Tablets 2.0: Generating a Revenue Plan for the Tablets Platform
December 8, 2011 1:30-3:00 p.m.
Available on Demand


All Events




min
Free Eletters — Sign up Now